# How to Dominate AI Search: Google vs ChatGPT vs Perplexity

> A massive empirical analysis compares AI search and Google. Discover the biases of generative engines and the GEO strategies that actually work.

- URL: https://traaker.ai/en/blog/geo-dominer-recherche-ia/
- Author: Aurélien Deixonne, AI Visibility Strategist (https://traaker.ai/en/authors/aurelien-deixonne/)
- Published: 2025-12-10
- Publisher: Traaker (https://traaker.ai)

> Based on the paper "Generative Engine Optimization: How to Dominate AI Search" by Chen, Wang, Chen & Koudas (University of Toronto). Published in September 2025.
>
> Paper: [arXiv:2509.08919](https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.08919)

---

## The Question Everyone Is Asking

ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini: these AI search engines are progressively replacing Google for more and more users. But **how do these systems choose their sources?** Are they similar to Google, or do they work in radically different ways?

This paper provides the first large-scale empirical answers. Researchers at the University of Toronto conducted controlled experiments across multiple verticals, languages, and query reformulations to compare AI search with traditional web search.

---

## The Protocol: A Massive Comparison

The researchers systematically compared:
- **Google** (traditional search)
- **Multiple AI search engines** (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini)

Across multiple dimensions:
- What types of sources are favored?
- How diverse are the domains?
- How fresh is the content?
- How stable are results across languages?
- How sensitive are results to query reformulation?

---

## Finding #1: The Massive Bias Toward Earned Media

This is the paper's most striking result. The researchers classify sources into three categories:

| Media type | Definition | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| **Brand-owned** | Content created and controlled by the brand | Official website, corporate blog |
| **Earned** | Third-party, independent, authoritative content | News articles, Wikipedia, expert reviews |
| **Social** | Social media content | Reddit, Twitter, forums |

**Google** presents a relatively balanced mix across these three types.

**AI search engines** show an **overwhelming and systematic bias toward earned media**: authoritative third-party sources. Brand-owned content and social content are largely ignored.

Concretely: if you're a brand relying on your own website to be visible in AI search, you have a problem. AI engines prefer what **others** say about you rather than what **you** say about yourself.

---

## Finding #2: Every AI Engine Is Different

Contrary to what one might think, AI search engines don't all behave the same way:

- **Domain diversity**: some engines cite many different sources, others concentrate on a few domains
- **Freshness**: some favor recent content, others don't
- **Cross-language stability**: the same query in English and French can yield very different sources
- **Reformulation sensitivity**: slightly rephrasing a question can completely change the cited sources

This means a GEO strategy that works on ChatGPT won't necessarily work on Perplexity or Gemini. **Optimization must be engine-specific.**

---

## Finding #3: The Big Brand Bias

AI search engines tend to favor well-known big brands. Niche players and small businesses are systematically underrepresented in generated responses.

This is an interesting paradox when compared to the [foundational GEO paper](https://traaker.ai/en/blog/geo-foundational-paper-explained/), which showed that GEO could help smaller sites. The reality is more nuanced: GEO can help smaller players gain visibility **once they're in the pool of considered documents**, but the initial bias of AI engines favors big brands for getting into that pool.

---

## The 4 Strategic Pillars of GEO According to This Study

Based on their empirical results, the researchers formulate a 4-point strategic agenda:

### 1. Content Engineering for Machines
Your content must be **scannable and justifiable by a machine**. This means:
- Clear, verifiable claims
- Structured data
- Cited sources that the LLM can verify

### 2. Dominate Earned Media
Since AI engines massively favor third-party sources, the most effective strategy is to **get others to talk about you**. Press articles, mentions in authoritative publications, expert reviews: this is what AI engines value.

### 3. Engine-Specific and Language-Specific Strategies
There is no universal strategy. Each AI engine has its own biases and preferences. Likewise, behavior varies by query language. Optimization must be tailored accordingly.

### 4. Overcoming the Big Brand Bias
For niche players, the key is to build **AI-perceived authority** through credibility signals: citations, data, mentions in authoritative sources.

---

## What This Changes Compared to Classic GEO

The foundational GEO paper focused on **how to modify your own content** (adding stats, citations, etc.). This study adds a crucial dimension: **what matters most is what others say about you.**

This is a paradigm shift. GEO is not just an on-page optimization exercise: it's also a public relations and authority-building strategy.

---

## Practical Implications

- **For brands**: invest in PR and earned media as much as in optimizing your website
- **For content creators**: position yourself as an authoritative source in your niche
- **For SEO professionals**: GEO requires different strategies depending on the targeted AI engine
- **For small businesses**: focus on building authority through third-party mentions

---

*Paper: Chen, M., Wang, X., Chen, K., & Koudas, N. (2025). Generative Engine Optimization: How to Dominate AI Search. [arXiv:2509.08919](https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.08919)*
